Recently, U.S. libraries have encountered a pressing issue: the escalating expenses associated with e-books. While these digital editions are highly sought-after by library users, their high costs and limitations present challenges for libraries striving to meet this demand.

Financial Strain Faced by Libraries

West Haven Public Library is one of the affected libraries. When popular authors like Robin Cook publish new medical thrillers, the library anticipates high demand for digital copies. Nonetheless, the expense of leasing these e-books can be significant. According to the Associated Press, a single hardcover copy of Cook's latest novel might cost the library $18, while leasing a digital copy can set them back $55 or more.

Additionally, e-books from libraries often have restrictions. Unlike books bought by individuals, which have no expiration date, library e-books usually expire after a set time or a specific number of checkouts. This results in libraries having to renew them to maintain patrons' access.

For libraries like West Haven, which may have limited budgets to begin with, these costs can quickly add up. In the last three years alone, the library has spent over $12,000 just to lease a few hundred additional digital titles. This is far less than what the same amount of money would have covered in physical books.

Libraries in Pennsylvania are also grappling with these increasing costs. York County Libraries witnessed a 5% rise in e-book demand over five years, allocating a significant portion of its budget to purchasing them. Robert Lambert, the president of York County Libraries, expressed concern over the pricing structure, which he believed contributes to a new digital divide. He advocated for publishers to modernize their licensing system to align with technological realities and ensure fair access for libraries and patrons.

Librarians and library patrons alike were feeling the impact of these soaring costs. Library users frequently face lengthy waitlists for in-demand e-books. In contrast, libraries grapple with budget limitations to maintain their collections. Despite their efforts, many libraries cannot provide the digital content desired and required by their patrons.

READ ALSO: The 2024 Longlist for the Women's Prize for Fiction Unveiled

Legislative Action and Publishers' Stance

To address this issue, librarians in several states have been pushing for legislative action. Bills were proposed in states like Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Illinois that aim to rein in the costs and restrictions on e-books. However, these efforts were met with strong opposition from the publishing industry, which argued that such measures would undermine intellectual property values and harm the publishing ecosystem.

Publishers contended that the arrangement is equitable. E-book licenses for libraries enable multiple patrons to borrow them, resulting in a per-reader cost significantly lower than the individual rate.

A bipartisan bill raised in 2022, led by State Rep. Eleni Kavros DeGraw and State Sen. Tony Hwang, aimed to prevent agreements with publishers or aggregators from imposing restrictions on library material loan periods or checkouts. Although the bill passed the committee, an unrelated amendment prevented its advancement to the floor for a vote.

Despite opposition from the Association of American Publishers, Lambert urged publishers and legislators to address the issue to prevent wasteful spending of taxpayer money. He emphasized the need for sustainable pricing models and legislative clarity to balance publishers' rights and public access to eBook materials.

RELATED ARTICLE: Gen Z Ignites a Book Renaissance: Embracing Physical Books and Revitalizing Libraries