The co-authored book on the Alex Murdaugh double-murder trial, written by Colleton County Clerk of Court Rebecca Hill and Neil Gordon, is facing a plagiarism scandal. Hill recently admitted to plagiarizing a significant portion of the book's opening section from the work of a BBC reporter. The co-author, Gordon, promptly suspended sales of the book and severed ties with Hill.
Gordon, who had been a vocal supporter of Hill, expressed his disappointment and announced his decision to discontinue any future collaborations with her after her private admission of plagiarism. The preface of Hill's book closely mirrored two drafts mistakenly sent to her by Honderich.
Hill's legal representatives released a statement on December 26, acknowledging her act of copying parts of the book's preface from BBC reporter Holly Honderich's work. The lawyers stated that the tight deadlines for the self-published book had pressured Hill. Attorneys Justin Bamberg and Will Lewis conveyed Hill's deep remorse for the incident.
This plagiarism revelation compounds the existing challenges for Hill, who is already under scrutiny for ethics violations and jury tampering during the Murdaugh trial. The book in question, titled 'Behind the Doors of Justice,' was initially self-published by the co-authors.
READ ALSO: A Guide to Reading 'Percy Jackson' Book Series in Order Following the New Series Adaptation
The preface of the book includes quotes from interviews conducted by Honderich, featuring four quotes from former U.S. Attorney Bill Nettles, three from Lexington lawyer Eric Bland, two from University of South Carolina professor Randy Covington, and one each from Columbia attorney Joe McCulloch, an unnamed waitress, and two different trial attendees.
The emails examined by Gordon were made public in response to Freedom of Information Act requests from media outlets. The emails that were released revealed that Honderich did not intend to share her work with Hill. Still, she mistakenly sent a draft to Hill due to address confusion. Hill replied to Honderich praising the article and saying she would delete it. Despite being instructed to delete the draft, Hill forwarded it to her personal email and the local paper's publisher. Hill's attorneys stated that she had contacted Honderich for an apology.
The book sold 14,000 copies before being withdrawn from sale and it is no longer available. Gordon, the publisher of 'Augusta Business Daily,' emphasized that he could not excuse or condone Hill's behavior.
Hill is reportedly dealing with two complaints filed at the State Ethics Commission. Additionally, law enforcement agents from the State Law Enforcement Division confiscated her phone in November, coinciding with the arrest of her son Jeffrey Hill, the former technology director of Colleton County. Jeffrey faced charges of wiretapping, with county officials suspecting him of unauthorized surveillance on his supervisor, according to records.
This plagiarism scandal raises serious questions about the integrity of Hill's work on the Murdaugh trial. It also highlights the importance of upholding ethical standards in legal reporting. According to Hill's legal representatives, the co-authors are currently deliberating on what to do with the book.
RELATED ARTICLE: Writer and Director Adam McKay Faces Lawsuit Over Alleged Similarities Between 'Don't Look Up' and William Collier's 'Stanley's Comet'