A federal judge in Iowa steps in to stop certain parts of an education law, Senate File (SF) 496, from taking effect. This law would have caused schools to remove hundreds of books from their libraries, causing concerns about freedom of speech and discrimination.

Judge Stephen Locher's decision prevents the enforcement of two provisions, one of which is a ban on books with sexually explicit content, which the judge believes may go against the First Amendment. Additionally, it blocks a part of the law that prohibits teaching about sexual orientation and gender identity in elementary schools, as the judge finds it unclear.

This injunction comes after a hearing on December 22 that combined two legal challenges from two groups - LGBTQ students who see the law as discriminatory and a group of educators along with publisher Penguin Random House who claim it infringes on their freedom of speech. The law was set to take effect on January 1, including provisions related to removing books from school libraries.

READ ALSO: Jean Twenge's New Book Dives Into the Differences Between Generations

Mike Beranek, president of the Iowa State Education Association and a plaintiff in the second lawsuit, stated that the ruling aims to allow educators to keep guiding students successfully without worrying about being punished or losing their jobs.

SF 496 introduced new standards for age-appropriate content in school library books, restricting the depiction or description of sexual acts. However, the judge expressed concern that the law was too broad and removed books widely recognized as important.

Governor Kim Reynolds expressed extreme disappointment with the ruling. According to Reynolds, teaching about gender identity and sexual orientation is not suitable for kindergarten through sixth-grade classrooms. The governor further stressed that books with sexually explicit content should not be in school libraries for children, as defined in Iowa law.

Attorney General Brenna Bird shares the same sentiment with Governor Reynolds, expressing her commitment to preventing inappropriate books from reaching children in schools.

In his December 29 ruling, Judge Locher expressed that SF 496 is an excessively broad law, stating that its section on gender identity and sexual orientation is so broadly written that any mention of relationships, whether gay or straight, could potentially violate the law.

Locher conveyed that the law, which restricts school library books and instruction on gender identity and sexual orientation in grades K-6, sends a moralistic message, implying that no value is redeemable in such books, even those considered important works.

However, a portion of the law requiring schools to notify parents when students ask to use a different name or pronoun was upheld. Locher stated that the LGBTQ students challenging this part of the law do not have standing, allowing this aspect to remain in effect.

Lambda Legal attorney Nathan Maxwell sees the ruling as a message against efforts to ban books based on LGBTQ+ content or suppress speech promoting inclusion for Iowa LGBTQ+ students. The two sections of the law covered by the injunction cannot be enforced while the lawsuits progress through the legal system.

RELATED ARTICLE: Iowa State Attorney Daniel Johnston Criticizes Overly Broad Book Bans in Schools Under SF 496