"Bridgerton" fans recently launched a petition urging Netflix to undo a major alteration to the storyline from the original book series.
The conclusion of season three introduced viewers to Michaela Stirling, a new character poised to be central in a queer love story with Francesca Bridgerton. However, in Julia Quinn's book "When He Was Wicked," the character is named Michael, a man with whom Francesca engages in a heterosexual relationship following the death of John Stirling, the Earl of Kilmartin.
The petition labels this alteration as a "travesty" and implores Netflix to reconsider its decision, advocating for fidelity to the source material. It emphasizes the profound connection readers have forged with the unaltered characters as penned by the author, asserting that any deviation risks diluting the essence of the beloved narrative. The petition has garnered over 16,000 signatures, underscoring the depth of sentiment among fans who cherish the original portrayal of Michael Stirling.
Signatories expressed concern that altering a character's identity could compromise the authenticity and emotional resonance of the storyline, potentially disappointing a broad audience. The petition clarifies that its goal is to maintain the integrity of the characters and their relationships as initially envisioned by the author, not to diminish LGBTQ+ representation.
READ ALSO: 'House of the Dragon' Season 2 Begins With a Controversial Twist in the 'Blood and Cheese' Murder
Fans are voicing their frustration through the comments. They argued that the series was supposed to ensure each sibling ends up with their intended partner from the books. Viewers felt that altering Michael's character to Michaela undermines the story's essence and accused the producers of making changes to meet diversity criteria.
The matter is similar to other past fan initiatives created around "Bridgerton." One campaign has over 50,000 signatures and calls for restored deleted scenes from season three. Supporters contended that upholding the novels' integrity and the bond readers have built with the series depends on being faithful to the books. The petition's impact underscores the passionate engagement of the "Bridgerton" community in safeguarding the essence of their beloved stories.
In an interview with Teen Vogue, Showrunner Jess Brownell explained that the decision to change the character's gender was a long-standing idea pitched since season one. Brownell, identifying as a queer woman, felt a personal connection to Francesca's feeling of difference in the book, interpreting it through a queer lens.
The intent was not to insert a queer character arbitrarily but to reflect a queer experience authentically. Brownell aimed to depict a meaningful queer narrative and joy, rarely seen in period pieces, while remaining true to the thematic essence of Francesca's character from the books. This approach was carefully researched to ensure a historically plausible and enriching storyline.
Brownell acknowledged thinking about the fans and their reactions when making significant decisions. As a showrunner, she learned it is impossible to please every part of the diverse fan base.
Brownell shared that she discussed the change with Quinn and received her approval. She recognized that any adaptation would likely disappoint some fans. Ultimately, the decision was driven by the story and character development, with Francesca's book resonating personally with her and lending itself naturally to the adaptation.
RELATED ARTICLE: 'Bridgerton' Season 3 Finale Breaks From Novel, Sets Stage for Queer Plot Twist With Francesca Bridgerton